Close Menu
Rethinking IslamRethinking Islam
  • Faith Unfiltered
    • Faith in Context
    • Ideas and Interpretation
  • Her Deen, Her Rules
    • Marriage and Family
    • Home and Everyday Living
  • Travel
    • Travel with Purpose
  • Did You Know?
    • Modern Questions
    • Thoughtful Reads This Week
    • Muslim Life in Singapore
  • Partner Spotlights
    • Just In
  • Between Us
  • Partner With Us

Subscribe to Updates

Get thoughtful stories about faith, modern Muslim life and Singapore in your inbox.

What's Hot

He Was Asked to Prove His Loyalty Because He Is Muslim. Then America Elected Him Senator.

November 4, 2026

When Dua Doesn’t Make the Pain Disappear: Can Muslims Seek Therapy Without Questioning Their Faith?

November 3, 2026

Child Maintenance in Singapore: What Muslim Parents Need to Know Before Money Becomes a Fight

November 2, 2026
Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram YouTube WhatsApp
Rethinking IslamRethinking Islam
Singapore’s Modern Muslim Magazine
  • Faith Unfiltered
    • Faith in Context
    • Ideas and Interpretation
  • Her Deen, Her Rules
    • Marriage and Family
    • Home and Everyday Living
  • Travel
    • Travel with Purpose
  • Did You Know?
    • Modern Questions
    • Thoughtful Reads This Week
    • Muslim Life in Singapore
  • Partner Spotlights
    • Just In
  • Between Us
  • Partner With Us
Rethinking IslamRethinking Islam
Home » You Think It Is Not Wrong. But What Does Islam Actually Ask?
Modern Questions

You Think It Is Not Wrong. But What Does Islam Actually Ask?

A. L. SaidBy A. L. SaidMay 17, 2026No Comments6 Mins Read
Share Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Reddit Telegram Email
Share
Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Pinterest Email

We Have Become Very Creative With Allah

Modern Muslims are actually quite impressive.

Not necessarily in patience.
Not necessarily in discipline.
Not necessarily in self control.

But in negotiation.

Human beings have always found ways to justify what they want. Modern life simply gives us new language, new pressures and new platforms for doing it.

Not openly, of course.

We do not usually say:
“I reject Allah’s commands.”

That sounds too dramatic.
Too dangerous.
Too obvious.

Instead, we say things like:

“Technically it is not wrong.”

“Allah knows my heart.”

“It is complicated.”

“Everyone does it.”

“At least I am not as bad as others.”

“It is just modern life.”

And somewhere along the way, many of us quietly stopped asking:

“Does Allah love this?”

And started asking:

“Can I emotionally justify this to myself?”

That is where the problem begins.

Not necessarily in the sin itself.

But in becoming too confident in our own reasoning.

Especially when society agrees with us.
Friends support us.
The internet validates us.
And our conscience slowly becomes quieter over time.

Because a quiet conscience does not always mean Allah is pleased.

Controversial Relationship With Allah

Perhaps the most dangerous spiritual condition today is not openly rejecting Allah.

It is quietly becoming too certain that Allah agrees with everything we have emotionally normalised.

Many people still want Allah in their lives.

They still make duas.
Still pray occasionally.
Still listen to Islamic reminders.
Still cry during difficult moments.
Still hope for barakah.

But somewhere deep inside, the relationship changes.

Allah is no longer fully obeyed.

He is slowly negotiated with.

Not through direct rebellion.
But through carefully edited reasoning.

We may begin filtering religion through comfort, culture, social approval, ego and convenience. Personal emotion and trauma also affect how people process religious demands, but they should be treated with care rather than mocked as mere excuses.

And after repeating our justifications long enough, our conscience becomes calmer.

That is the frightening part.

Modern culture often gives strong weight to individual autonomy and emotional wellbeing. Those values can be beneficial in some situations, but a Muslim still has to ask whether a choice also fits the ethical and legal principles of Islam.

But Islam never taught us to worship our emotions.

Islam taught us to struggle against ourselves too.

And perhaps that is the real controversial relationship many people have with Allah today.

Not disbelief.

But self legitimising spirituality.

“Everyone Does It” Has Become a Spiritual Argument

One of the most dangerous sentences today is:

“Everyone does it.”

Backbiting becomes normal office bonding.

Mocking others becomes “just jokes.”

Flirting becomes “harmless.”

Harsh speech becomes “being real.”

Public humiliation becomes “speaking facts.”

Slowly, sins stop looking ugly because society keeps repainting them.

And once something becomes socially common, many people unconsciously assume Allah must understand and tolerate it too.

But normalisation has never been proof of righteousness.

Entire societies can normalize things while still being spiritually unhealthy.

That is why the believer should fear not only sin.

But also the death of discomfort toward sin.

Some Grudges Are Not About Pain Anymore. They Are About Ego

This is becoming very common today.

People cut off siblings,
relatives,
friends,
or even parents for years.

Not because reconciliation is impossible.

But because pride slowly becomes disguised as “protecting my peace.”

Of course, Islam does not force people to remain in abusive or dangerous relationships.

Boundaries matter.

Mental wellbeing matters.

But sometimes, if we are brutally honest, the distance is no longer about healing.

It becomes punishment.

A silent emotional revenge.

And the frightening part is how spiritually justified we can start feeling while holding onto arrogance for years.

Especially when everyone around us says:
“You do not owe anyone anything.”

Maybe not.

The better question is whether the boundary is protecting someone from harm or whether pride, punishment and refusal to reconcile have become mixed into it. Only ALLAH fully knows what is inside the heart.

Harsh With Others. Flexible With Ourselves.

Some people become extremely strict when judging others.

But strangely flexible when justifying themselves.

When others make mistakes, suddenly religion becomes very serious.

But when they themselves need convenience, exceptions suddenly appear everywhere.

This selective strictness is dangerous because it slowly turns personal benefit into a moral compass.

For example, some may speak aggressively about gender interaction,
modesty, or religious boundaries when discussing others.

Yet when convenience benefits them personally, the same strictness suddenly becomes “context.” This can be seen in office or transport or school gender mixing settings.

That inconsistency deserves self examination. Context can genuinely change a ruling, but convenience should not be disguised as context without evidence.

And perhaps deep down, many people already know it.

Preaching Is Easy. Internal Accountability Is Hard.

Islam does not require perfection before advising others.

Otherwise nobody would be qualified to remind anyone.

But there is still danger when preaching becomes easier than self reflection.

Today, it is possible to post reminders,
share Quran verses,
upload motivational Islamic content,
and still avoid confronting our own unchecked behavior honestly.

Sometimes religion becomes presentation instead of transformation.

Public religious expression can sometimes create a sense of progress that is not matched by private conduct. That is a reason for self examination, not a licence to judge the sincerity of everyone who shares Islamic content online.

We Fear Social Disapproval More Than Displeasing Allah

This may be one of the quietest spiritual crises of modern life.

Many people today do not ask:

“Is this pleasing to Allah?”

They ask:

“Will society accept this?”
“Will people judge me?”
“Will I still fit in?”
“Will this make my life harder?”

And slowly, social comfort becomes more emotionally important than spiritual caution.

Especially in fast moving societies like Singapore where modern life rewards convenience, image management, and emotional comfort.

For many believers, the more ordinary challenge is not dramatic rejection of faith but small compromises made under social pressure, convenience or fear of standing out.

The Most Frightening Possibility

One of the most frightening possibilities in modern life is this:

A person may spend years believing they are spiritually safe…
while quietly normalising what Allah dislikes.

Not because they rejected Islam.

But because they became too skilled at explaining themselves to themselves.

Every decision had a reason.
Every compromise had context.
Every controversy had emotional justification.

And slowly,
the heart stopped trembling.

Perhaps that is the real controversial relationship with Allah today.

Not open disbelief.

But the quiet confidence that whatever we choose,
Allah will naturally understand.

Even if deep down…
we never seriously asked whether He approved.

Related Reads

• When Desire Borrows Religious Language

• Trailblazing Muslimahs

Donate Now

Was this useful?

Share the conversation

WhatsAppTelegram

Rethinking Islam

Keep thinking with us.

Get fresh perspectives on faith and Muslim life in Singapore. Subscribe free.

Mailchimp opens in a new tab to complete your signup. Privacy policy

Continue exploring

He Was Asked to Prove His Loyalty Because He Is Muslim. Then America Elected Him Senator.Why Do Muslim Women Cover Their Hair When Praying Alone?Why He Began Talking to Allah Every Day
FEATURED SPONSOR
ARLC Legal logo
Abdul Rahman Law CorporationLegal guidance for families in Singapore
Book a legal consultation ↗
Sponsored feature · General information only
A quieter corner
If you are looking for a quieter space to reflect without pressure, you are welcome to step inside.
Enter the quiet space
modern muslim struggles Islamic accountability Islam and conscience Muslim reflection self legitimising in Islam controversial relationship with Allah modern Islam challenges faith and ego spiritual self deception Singapore Muslim reflections
Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email
Previous ArticleMarriage Is More Than Two Independent Lives Under One Roof
Next Article Taawwudh and Bismillah: Two Islamic Phrases That Help Us Pause
A. L. Said

    A. L. Said is a Singaporean writer and editor with an academic background in Economics and Management from the University of London.\n\nHis interests span society, culture, human behaviour, belief systems and the changing realities of modern life. Drawing on years of independent study, diverse intellectual perspectives and conversations across communities, he explores questions that often deserve more attention than conventional explanations allow.\n\nThrough Rethinking Islam, he brings an investigative and reflective approach to contemporary issues, combining research, critical inquiry and accessible storytelling. His work also connects professional expertise and business perspectives with meaningful editorial content.\n\nHe believes good writing should do more than inform. It should encourage people to question assumptions, examine different perspectives and, occasionally, rethink what they thought they knew.

    Related Posts

    Editor's Picks

    He Was Asked to Prove His Loyalty Because He Is Muslim. Then America Elected Him Senator.

    November 4, 2026
    Editor's Picks

    Why Do Muslim Women Cover Their Hair When Praying Alone?

    October 10, 2026
    Thoughtful Reads This Week

    Why He Began Talking to Allah Every Day

    October 6, 2026
    Add A Comment
    Leave A Reply Cancel Reply

    Top Posts

    Halal Investing in Singapore: A Practical Guide for Muslims

    September 19, 202547,410 Views

    Loans in Singapore: When Necessity Knocks, What Do We Do?

    September 19, 202543,899 Views

    Can a Jinn Fall in Love with a Human? What Islam Actually Says

    March 9, 202416,941 Views

    Hijab Is Not Just a Scarf: The Truth We Rarely Talk About

    February 14, 20267,087 Views
    Stay In Touch
    • Facebook
    • Instagram
    • WhatsApp

    Subscribe to Updates

    Join our newsletter for deep dives into faith, spirituality, and modern Muslim thought.

    Your brand banner on Rethinking Islam
    Your brand name can appear here
    Banner Space Available
    Reach engaged readers who care about money, values and real life decisions
    Strong Singapore and regional traffic
    Audience that trusts thoughtful content
    Simple reporting for views and clicks
    Enquire About This Banner

    Explore Trusted Muslim Friendly Services

    Discover professionals and businesses aligned with your needs and values.

    View Directory
    Discover Trusted Services
    Featured Partners

    Discover Trusted Services

    Tap a sponsor video only when you want to watch it.

    ⌕ RI Services Directory Find Muslim Friendly Contacts →
    Traditional scents for a new generation

    Attar, oud and personalised fragrance discovery in Kampong Gelam.

    Visit Royal Fragrances →
    Trusted legal guidance for life and family

    Syariah matters, Wasiat, Hibah, estate planning and probate support in Singapore.

    Book a Consultation →
    Private Digital Reflection Enter Your Backroom A short interactive experience built around the choices you actually make. Enter the Experience →
    Swipe or use arrows
    Partner features are provided for reader discovery. Please review each service independently.

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.

    Instagram Wordpress
    Copyright © 2026 Rethinking Islam | Powered by Pearl Organisation

    About Us | WhatsApp +65 8905 1786 | info@rethinkingislam.net